Derek Brunson sat down on The Ariel Helwani Show this week and said the thing most retired contenders only mutter at the bar. “I would have been the greatest fighter of all time if it wasn’t for this,” he told Helwani. Then, before anyone could reach for the obvious punchline, he grabbed it himself: “This ain’t CTE. This is real talk.”
Fine. I’ll take him at his word on the CTE part. The GOAT part is where the numbers get rude.
The Record He’s Arguing From
Brunson went 14-7 across 11 years in the UFC and sits at 24-9 overall. Bloody Elbow points out he was widely viewed as a gatekeeper until a five-fight winning streak between 2019 and 2022, and that run ended with hard losses to Jared Cannonier and Dricus du Plessis. He left the promotion without ever fighting for a belt. His seven UFC losses came against Cannonier, Du Plessis, Israel Adesanya, Jacare Souza, Anderson Silva, Robert Whittaker and Yoel Romero.
View post on X
You can build a lot of things out of that résumé. A respectable career, sure. A guy nobody wanted to see on the way up, absolutely. A greatest-of-all-time case? I’ve talked myself into some ugly tickets late at night, and even I wouldn’t sign that one.
His Actual Argument
To be fair to him, Brunson laid out a theory instead of just shouting a conclusion. He pointed to fighters getting cut lately even with decent records, guys who win but don’t finish. Seeing that, he said, he switched to a more aggressive approach to appease the brass. “You had to go out there and you couldn’t really fight your style,” he told Helwani, adding that the message was always “if you want that title fight, you better go out there and make it a great fight.”
The part I’ll buy is his point about how title shots get handed out. He said fighters should still put on good fights, but “there should be a way you earn that fight.” That’s a reasonable gripe, and plenty of fighters have made it before him.
Where his theory falls apart is the bit about what the aggressive version of Derek Brunson actually produced. MMA Mania notes he finished his UFC run 14-7 with nine finishes and three post-fight bonuses, two of them Fight of the Night. That’s the guy who got paid. That’s the guy who got the five-fight streak and the ranked matchups. The style he says held him back is the same style that kept him employed and in the conversation.
And look at who beat him. Brunson himself said he was “super good that none of these guys outside the Top 10 would beat me. So I always got stuck fighting, you know, Top 10.” Read that again. His own explanation is that he kept running into elite middleweights and losing to them. Changing tactics doesn’t turn a 14-7 run into a GOAT run. A more conservative game plan against that loss list probably just turns some knockouts into decisions.
The Money Is the Real Story
The most honest stretch of the interview had nothing to do with legacy. Brunson admitted part of him regrets asking for his UFC release with two fights left on his deal, because pay went up after the Paramount+ streaming agreement. “I could be doing what Bobby Green is doing,” he said. He also joked that “the UFC owe me some money with back pay in terms of all the finishes I got,” citing the new $25,000 for a finish and the $100,000 Fight of the Night bonus he says replaced the old $50,000.
That’s a guy looking at a payout schedule that showed up a couple of years too late for him. I get it. Nobody likes cashing out right before the line moves. But it’s a timing complaint, and dressing it up as a GOAT argument makes it harder to take seriously, which is a shame, because the timing complaint is legit.
Friday’s Problem
Now the part I care about professionally. Brunson hasn’t competed in MMA since a winning PFL debut against Ray Cooper III in November 2023. He’s 42. He makes his BKFC debut against Theo Doukas this Friday, November 20, in Myrtle Beach, following Mike Perry, Eddie Alvarez, Luke Rockhold and Chad Mendes into the bare-knuckle business. Bloody Elbow reports he’s already eyeing Darren Till, whom he submitted in a UFC Fight Night main event at the Apex five years ago.
A 42-year-old coming off a long layoff, switching sports, with a callout already loaded for the next fight? That’s my least favorite profile in the book. If a sportsbook hangs a short price on him, I’ll be standing on the other side of the counter.
There’s no takedown to fall back on in a bare-knuckle ring, and no style to switch back to. Brunson spent his whole interview telling Helwani he got pushed into barnburners. On Friday in Myrtle Beach, a barnburner is the only thing on the menu.





