Next UFC Fight Night: Procházka vs. Stirling, Sat, Nov 21 (Procházka vs. Stirling)Results UFC 334Ciryl Gane def. Josh HokitKayla Harrison def. Amanda NunesCaio Borralho def. Yousri BelgarouiLuis Gurule def. Bilal HasanStephen Thompson def. Charles Radtke
Opinion

Sean O'Malley Torches Ciryl Gane Over Eye Pokes, and Hokit's Own Math Backs Him Up

Josh Hokit says Gane poked his eye 40 seconds into their UFC 334 title fight, nothing happened, and one point would have forced a draw.

Sean O'Malley
Photo: Sean O'Malley: U.S. Department of the Interior, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Sean O’Malley went after Ciryl Gane for eye pokes at UFC 334, according to Yahoo Sports. The former bantamweight champion picked the right target, though the man who deserves most of the heat wasn’t wearing gloves that night.

Start with the guy whose eye got poked. Josh Hokit posted on X, tagging the UFC and Dana White, that Gane got him 40 seconds into the fight. Hokit said he complained and got no help. He fought the rest of a five-round heavyweight title fight with what he described as a busted eye, lost on the cards, and spent the following days making his case for an immediate rematch.

I’ve read a lot of losing-fighter manifestos. Most of them are about judging, and most of them should be ignored. Hokit’s has a judging section too, and I’ll get to it. Buried inside it is the one argument that actually holds.

The point that never came off

Hokit’s complaint about Round 1 is worth reading closely. He says he slammed Gane, held top position and finished the round throwing elbows, yet two judges gave the round to Gane. Then he wrote this: “Should have been a 10-8 or 9-9 if Marc gave a sh*t about doing his job.” And then: “A draw would have made the rematch automatic.”

Forget the 10-8. That’s a fighter scoring his own round, which is like letting a guy grade his own math test. The 9-9 is the interesting number, because a 9-9 in that spot comes from exactly one thing: the referee taking a point from Gane for the poke. By Hokit’s own arithmetic, one deducted point turns a loss into a draw, and a draw at heavyweight title level means the rematch books itself.

That’s the whole fight over foul enforcement in a single scorecard. Referees hand out warnings in championship fights like breath mints because warnings cost nothing. A point deduction changes who leaves with the belt, so nobody wants to be the official who decided it. My view is that the stakes make the deduction more necessary. If a foul 40 seconds in can hand one fighter a damaged eye for 25 minutes, the other fighter should pay something for it on the cards. Otherwise the rule just sits there, unenforced, waiting for the next title fight to ignore it.

O’Malley has spent his whole career as a striker who lives on distance and vision. If anybody understands what a poked eye does to your ability to read a jab, it’s him.

Where Hokit loses me

The rest of Hokit’s case is weaker. He says Gane “sprinted away from me for 3 straight rounds” and that “Volume that doesn’t hurt nobody isn’t winning a fight.” He says his coaches thought he was ahead going into the fifth and that Gane’s coach told Gane he needed a knockout.

Maybe. Coaches in both corners say all kinds of things between rounds to light a fire. Judges scored it for the guy landing more, and Hokit chasing for 25 minutes doesn’t change that.

People watched the same fight and came away with wildly different takes. Robert Whittaker, speaking on the MMArcade Podcast, sounded amazed by Hokit’s pressure, saying “The guy took four billion shots, man. He just walked him down, gung-ho, and turned it into his fight.” Jon Jones, meanwhile, posted on X that Gane “show glimpses of Muhammad Ali” and was “So light on his feet just popping that jab.” The post Jones was quoting went further and claimed Hokit didn’t land a single strike, which is the kind of thing nobody believes, including probably the person who typed it.

Read those two side by side. Whittaker is praising Hokit’s chin, his commitment, his ability to take punishment. Jones is praising Gane’s jab. Neither one is describing a fight Hokit won on effective striking. The poke argument is the only part of Hokit’s case that rests on the rulebook. Everything else is about which kind of fighting you like better.

The sideshow

Hokit isn’t making this easy on himself. Alexander Volkov told Ariel Helwani that Hokit flipping off Bruce Buffer at UFC 334 “crosses the line.” Hokit answered on X by mocking Volkov’s claim that Buffer’s job is harder than fighting. Conor McGregor then called Hokit, “outside of myself,” the biggest draw in the UFC and welcomed him to Paradigm Sports, signing off with “CONTRACTMAXXING 101.”

So Hokit now has McGregor’s management company and a Buffer feud. That’s a lot of noise around a guy whose best argument is a quiet, boring, procedural one about a referee not taking a point.

Hokit also wrote that “almost any fight you make with Ciryl right now is a recycled rematch anyway,” naming Volkov or “Alex.” He’s got a point there too. If the division’s options are reruns either way, the rerun with a legitimate foul dispute attached has more of a case than the others.

O’Malley is right to be angry about the pokes. The UFC should give Hokit the rematch on that basis alone, ignore his Round 1 scoring, and tell whoever referees it that the first poke costs a point. Gane is good enough to win without his fingers in anybody’s eye.

Keep reading