Next UFC Fight Night: Procházka vs. Stirling, Sat, Nov 21 (Procházka vs. Stirling)Results UFC 334Ciryl Gane def. Josh HokitKayla Harrison def. Amanda NunesCaio Borralho def. Yousri BelgarouiLuis Gurule def. Bilal HasanStephen Thompson def. Charles Radtke
Opinion

Mighty Mouse Torched Gane vs. Hokit, but the Missed Eye Poke Is the Bigger Scandal

Brendan Schaub scored UFC 334 3-2 for Josh Hokit and says a poke in the opening minute should have cost Ciryl Gane a point.

Ciryl Gane and Josh Hokit
Photo: Ciryl Gane: The White House, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons | Josh Hokit: U.S. Army photo by Sgt. 1st Class Brittany Primavera, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Demetrious Johnson has watched more fights than almost anyone alive, so when he says he’d rather put on K-1 than sit through a UFC heavyweight title fight, I listen. Reacting on his @MightyMouse channel, in a clip Happy Punch posted to X, Johnson said of Ciryl Gane vs. Josh Hokit: “What are we watching right now? This is literally fcking horrible. I’d rather watch K-1 kickboxing than this sht… I am so disappointed.”

Fair enough. Former flyweight champions are allowed to have taste. But since Saturday night, two separate complaints have gotten knotted together. One is that the UFC 334 main event was ugly. The other is that Hokit got robbed. Gane kept the belt on the cards, and the reactions went everywhere. Yahoo Sports ran its fighter roundup under the line “Right man won.” MMA Sucka reported that Joaquin Buckley lost his cool watching the main event. Alex Pereira walked up to Hokit afterward and told him he thought Hokit won, and Hokit’s answer, per Happy Punch, was “Chama.”

My position: the judges are the wrong target. If this fight was bent, it was bent in the first minute by the referee, and that’s where the anger should go.

The First Minute

THE MMA GURU wrote on X that Hokit was eye poked badly in the opening minute of the biggest fight of his life, then told to fight on with no break and no point deduction. Brendan Schaub went harder. He called Goddard the best referee in the game, then said that failing to see an illegal poke from Gane, a fighter Schaub described as notorious for it, was unacceptable after what he called months of complaints from fans, fighters and UFC brass.

I’ll be careful, because neither post breaks the foul down frame by frame. But take both descriptions at face value and the problem compounds fast. Hokit got no recovery time, so he spent the rest of that round fighting a heavyweight champion with a damaged eye. And with no deduction, a close opening round went to the judges as a clean round. Every scorecard that followed was built on top of that missed call.

What Schaub’s Card Actually Concedes

Schaub laid out his scoring in detail, which I appreciate, because most robbery takes are vibes with capital letters. He had Round 1 for Hokit but called it close. He gave Rounds 2 and 3 to Hokit and said those weren’t really debatable. Then he scored Rounds 4 and 5 for Gane, saying the champion gained momentum in the championship rounds, and tipped his cap to Gane as one tough SOB. His conclusion was 3-2 Hokit, or a draw at worst.

The draw scenario is where his argument lives. If you gave Gane the first round, Schaub says, the poke should have been a point deduction, making it 9-9. If you had Hokit winning it, the deduction makes it 10-8 Hokit.

Now read that card again. By Schaub’s own breakdown, a judge who scored a close Round 1 for Gane, plus the final two, has Gane winning 3-2 with zero deduction on the books. That card is perfectly legitimate. Judges can’t take points. They score the fight the referee hands them. So the robbery case rests on a close round plus a point that was never taken, and only one of those things is a judging failure. The other is officiating.

I’m usually the first person complaining about 10-8 rounds handed out like candy, so let me be clear that Schaub’s hypothetical 10-8 doesn’t bother me. A 10-8 produced by a foul deduction is the rulebook doing its job. A judge inventing one because a round felt dominant is a different crime entirely.

Hokit Earned the Noise

Hokit gave everybody a reason to care about this fight before it started. Championship Rounds posted video of what it framed as another drunk arrival at the weigh-in, with Hokit passing out on the scale and lying still for more than a minute. Happy Punch caught him flipping off Bruce Buffer during his introduction, after Buffer had previously criticized his antics. Amanda Nunes, per Championship Rounds, loved one of his press conference lines, which I will not be reprinting for my editor’s sake.

Then the cage door closed and he backed it up. The MMA GURU described him taking that poke and still marching forward on a man much bigger than him, and Schaub said the Hokit train only got bigger, signing off with “BURN. THE. BOATS.” You don’t get Pereira telling you that you won unless you did something real in there.

Johnson’s complaint still stands on its own. A fight can be grueling and close and also unpleasant to watch, and Mighty Mouse doesn’t owe anyone a good review. But an ugly fight is a taste problem. A title fight swung by a foul nobody penalized is a competition problem, and only the second one should keep the UFC up at night.

Gane leaves UFC 334 with the belt and a card you can defend. Goddard should leave with the tape of that first minute, because that 60 seconds is the whole controversy.

Keep reading